The Price of Silence

Create up to 20 seconds from 0:00. Available for free opening episodes. Preparing a clip downloads this episode on your device.

Mara read the last line aloud.

“Don't leave the light on. Open the door.”

Noah waited at the keys.

“It sounds like an order,” she said.

“It can.”

“Or somebody finally asking for something.”

“That too.”

She sang it once, quietly. The melody climbed where she expected it to fall. She tried again, keeping the final word open instead of decorating it. Noah came in beneath her voice, not answering this time but agreeing.

When they finished, he looked at her for so long that she had to remind herself they were in a theatre, in daylight, with a cleaner vacuuming the foyer.

“I mean it,” she said.

“I heard.”

The old melody did not become their new duet. They agreed it belonged to the work still being untangled. But the new line showed them what the new song needed: less waiting, more asking. By lunchtime they had written a chorus that sounded like two people risking an answer.

Ines listened twice. Then she put her notebook down.

“That's the finale.”

Mara felt the old thrill of something taking shape outside her own head. Noah reached for her hand beneath the piano's edge. His thumb moved once over her knuckles.

During the afternoon rehearsal, a photographer arrived with a list of poses. One placed Noah slightly behind Mara, his hands on the piano while she faced the camera. Mara asked to see the frame.

“No,” she said. “Beside each other.”

The photographer adjusted without complaint. Noah looked at her with an expression she could not quite read.

Later he asked whether she had done it for him.

“For the picture,” she said. “It was wrong.”

He nodded. Then he reached up and straightened the collar of her jacket, a small intimate gesture made in front of the whole room. Mara stood still beneath his hands. She had spent years craving grand declarations. This ordinary willingness to be seen caring for her made her pulse stumble more than any speech.

“Is that all right?” he asked quietly.

“Yes.”

She caught his wrist before he stepped away and kissed the inside of it. Somebody called them back to their places. Neither hurried. For a few seconds she allowed the warmth between them to exist without checking whether it fitted the story someone else intended to tell.

They had dinner at the workshop flat because Mara wanted to cook something that did not arrive in paper. The tiny oven burned one side of the vegetables and neglected the other. Noah cut away the blackened edges without comment.

“You used to make a speech about this,” she said.

“I've become less interesting.”

“No. Just more useful.”

She poured wine into the mismatched mugs. They sat on the floor because the table was covered with costume repairs. Above them, somebody in the neighbouring flat practised a trumpet badly and with admirable confidence.

Noah raised his mug. “To professional jealousy.”

“Of the trumpet?”

“Absolutely. That person has never doubted a note.”

Mara laughed until she had to put her mug down. Noah watched her, smiling, and then stopped.

“What?” she asked.

“I remembered how much I wanted this.”

“Burnt vegetables?”

“You, when you're not performing an acceptable evening.”

She moved closer. Their knees touched. He set his mug safely on the table this time, and she kissed him before he could make a joke about it.

There was nothing tentative in the way she wanted him now. There was care, which was different. When he paused with his hand at her waist, she drew him nearer. When she rested her forehead against his shoulder, he waited until she lifted her face.

“Stay,” she said.

“For tonight?”

“For tonight. We can talk about tomorrow when it's tomorrow.”

He nodded. She took his hand and led him away from the lamplight, leaving the dishes, the pages, and the ruined vegetables where they were.

Later, the trumpet had stopped. Mara lay listening to Noah's breathing and the uncertain pipes. She felt happier than seemed reasonable, given all the things still wrong.

He traced the seam of the pillowcase with one finger.

“There's something about that week,” he said. “Something I should have told you when we spoke about the letter.”

She turned toward him. “Tell me.”

He sat up. Before he could continue, her phone began vibrating on the floor. She ignored it. Then his phone sounded from his coat.

Ines had called both of them.

Mara answered. The producer's voice was flat with controlled anger.

“Your father's sent a recording to the sponsor. You need to hear it before you talk to anyone.”

Noah's face went still.

They listened together, the phone between them on the blanket. Stefan's recorded voice sounded younger, but not less certain. He was offering money in return for a signed release and the end of a dispute over the album. Then Noah's voice asked when the payment could clear.

“Tomorrow,” Stefan said on the recording. “If we're agreed that Mara doesn't need to be burdened with this.”

There was a pause. A chair creaked.

“All right,” Noah's recorded voice answered.

Mara stopped the audio.

Outside the window a lorry reversed into the alley. Its warning beep filled the silence between them.

“How much?” she asked.

“Eighteen thousand.”

“For your share of the songs?”

“And my silence.”

She pulled the blanket around herself, suddenly conscious of being unclothed in a room where somebody had changed the temperature.

“You let me tell you what I signed.”

“Yes.”

“You stood there while I explained how ashamed I was.”

“I am ashamed too.”

“Then why did I have to hear it from him?”

Noah looked toward his coat, then back at her. He did not reach for it.

“I was trying to tell you.”

“After this.” She gestured between them. “After I asked you to stay.”

“Yes.”

The answer was worse because it contained no defence.

Mara got dressed in the bathroom. She took longer than she needed, folding a towel, putting the cap on a bottle, performing little acts of order because she could not find a larger one.

When she returned, Noah was dressed and sitting on the chair. He had not made the bed.

“My brother's accident was three days before that meeting,” he said.

She remembered the hospital flowers, the unanswered messages, the first rehearsal he had missed. The dates rearranged themselves, but not into forgiveness.

“Did Eli need the money?”

“Yes.”

“Does that make it all right that you kept it from me now?”

“No.”

She stood by the door. He looked tired and frightened and unbearably familiar. She wanted to put her hand on his face. She wanted him gone. Both desires felt like betrayal.

Ines called again. Mara let it ring until it stopped.

“Tomorrow,” she said. “Tell me everything tomorrow. Tonight I need you to leave.”

Noah rose. At the door he turned, not to touch her but to make sure she was looking at him.

“I didn't sell being in love with you,” he said. “But I did accept money to make leaving easier. You deserve to know both.”

After he left, her father called. She answered because she wanted, suddenly and fiercely, to hear him admit why he had chosen tonight.

“Now do you understand?” he asked.

“I understand that you recorded a frightened man agreeing to something and kept it for seven years.”

“I protected you.”

“You sent it to a sponsor before you sent it to me.”

“The concert is at risk.”

“Then you should have considered that before using it to punish me.”

Stefan went quiet. For the first time in her life, Mara could hear him searching for the sentence that would put him back in charge. She did not supply one.

“He took the money,” he said finally.

“Yes. He did. You don't get to be innocent because somebody else isn't.”

She ended the call and sat with the phone in her lap. The words had surprised her. She could say them to her father and still need to hear them herself. Noah's failure did not erase her signature. Her signature did not oblige her to forgive his silence. She had wanted love to simplify the past. Instead it was asking her to look at the whole of it.

Then Mara listened to the final part of the recording. Stefan asked whether Noah wanted her told that the dispute was settled.

Noah's younger voice answered after a long silence.

“Tell her whatever makes it easiest.”

Mara sat down on the unmade bed. There was no missing letter that could undo that sentence.