The Wrong Introduction

Create up to 20 seconds from 0:00. Available for free opening episodes. Preparing a clip downloads this episode on your device.

The piano played the wrong introduction, and Mara Voss forgot how to breathe.

Not a wrong note. That would have been easy. This was a melody she had last heard seven years ago, through a kitchen wall, while a man she loved washed a single blue plate. Nobody at the Bellhaven theatre should have known it. The song had never been released.

Mara stood behind the curtain with her engagement ring caught in the lining of her sleeve. Beyond the velvet, a hundred invited guests waited for a preview of her anniversary concert. Her father was in the front row. Her fiancé had arranged the flowers. Her former lover was apparently sitting at the piano.

She pulled her hand free and walked into the light.

Noah Reed looked up. His hair was shorter, his face leaner. The little scar at his eyebrow remained. He played the final chord with one hand and held out the other toward the empty microphone, as though seven years were a delayed entrance he could forgive.

Mara could have left. She thought about it until the audience began applauding.

Instead she sang.

The words belonged to a different song, her first hit, but Noah caught the change immediately. He shifted beneath her voice. Once, this had been their private pleasure: she could turn anywhere, and he would make a road. Tonight it felt like somebody opening a locked room while strangers admired the furniture.

At the end she took her bow without looking at him.

Backstage, she found him folding a pair of spectacles into his coat pocket.

“You don't wear glasses.”

“I do when I want to see.”

“Who invited you?”

“Ines.” He nodded toward the producer approaching along the corridor. “I assumed she told you.”

Ines carried two paper cups and the expression of a woman who had found a fire where she had expected a rehearsal. “Your office confirmed the accompanist change yesterday.”

“My father's office.”

“I specifically asked that you approve it.”

Mara took neither cup. “He didn't tell me.”

Noah's mouth changed. Not anger yet. Something more tired.

“I'll go,” he said.

“No.” The word escaped before she could decide whether she meant it. She lowered her voice. “You don't get to appear, play that, and go.”

“I was checking the piano. I didn't know your microphone was open.”

For an instant his old embarrassment was visible. It made her angrier than any calculated entrance could have. He had been playing their unfinished melody for himself.

Simon arrived with Mara's father. Stefan Voss moved quickly despite his immaculate shoes, smiling the smile he used when other people had made an expensive mistake.

“Noah. What an unexpected pleasure.”

“You confirmed him,” Ines said.

“My assistant confirms a great many things.” Stefan turned to Mara. “We need photographs before the guests leave.”

She watched Noah watching her father. Neither man offered a hand.

Simon touched her elbow. “Darling, you're shaking.”

“I'm cold.”

Noah glanced at the sleeve she had torn. He knew when she was lying. He had once known every version of her fear, including the one that sounded like impatience.

Simon took off his jacket and placed it around her shoulders. The gesture was kind. She wished she could feel only gratitude.

“We should discuss the concert tomorrow,” she told Ines. “All of us. Without my father's assistant.”

Stefan's smile tightened.

Mara stayed for the photographs. In each one she stood beside Simon, a man who remembered her food allergies, never raised his voice, and had proposed in a restaurant where the staff already knew she would say yes. He had not asked them to expect a refusal. Neither had she.

After the final guest left, Simon drove her home. He spoke about the concert's sponsor and the house they had viewed on Sunday. There was room for a recording studio in the garden. He said this as though a room were the same thing as permission to use it.

At a red light he looked across at her.

“You knew the pianist.”

“Yes.”

“How well?”

She could have said they had worked together. It would have been true in the way a photograph of the sea was water.

“I lived with him.”

The light changed. Simon did not move until the car behind sounded its horn.

“You might have mentioned that.”

“I didn't know he'd be there.”

“I meant before tonight.”

Before they reached the flat, Simon stopped outside the florist that had supplied the theatre. A member of staff was waiting with the arrangements he had paid to keep. Mara helped lift them into the boot. One stem broke, scattering pale petals across her sleeve.

“Leave it,” Simon said. “They'll replace it.”

She held the broken flower anyway. In the early years, she and Noah had taken flowers left after other people's concerts and put them in jam jars. Tonight there were enough perfect arrangements to fill a room, and she could not remember having asked for any of them.

Simon saw her expression and misread it.

“I wanted the evening to feel special.”

“I know. That was kind.”

He shut the boot. “You make kindness sound like something I should apologise for.”

Mara looked at him properly. He was tired, worried, trying. Whatever had happened backstage did not excuse treating him as a prop in her revelation.

“I'm sorry,” she said. “You haven't done anything wrong.”

He nodded, but neither of them believed that being blameless would make this simple.

At home he put the kettle on. They stood on opposite sides of the kitchen island, a marble country neither had crossed all evening.

“Do you still love him?” he asked.

Mara looked at her ring. It was beautiful. She had helped choose it, because Simon disliked surprises that might disappoint.

“I don't know what I feel.”

“That is quite an answer.”

“It is the honest one.”

He nodded once, then took his untouched mug into the sitting room. Mara did not follow. She had spent too many years treating the end of a difficult conversation as proof that it had been resolved.

The next morning she arrived at the theatre before her father. Noah sat on the stage with a cup balanced on the piano lid. He moved it when she looked at it.

“You still hate that.”

“It leaves a ring.”

“Some things do.”

She refused to smile. He refused to help her refuse.

Ines explained the proposal. The concert would pair Mara with a songwriter from her early years. Two established performers, equal fees, a new duet for the broadcast finale. Another musician had withdrawn. Noah's recent album had made him an obvious replacement, professionally speaking.

Professionally speaking. Mara nearly laughed.

“My office said he wasn't available,” she said.

“Your father said you wouldn't want him.”

“He doesn't decide what I want.”

Both Ines and Noah were merciful enough not to answer.

There were practical questions: rehearsal hours, credit, a separate agreement for the new song. Noah asked that both writers approve every version. Mara said yes before Ines finished writing the sentence.

Then Stefan walked in.

“I've spoken to the sponsor. They prefer someone with a more recognisable name.”

“Noah sold out his last tour,” Ines said.

“Small rooms.”

“Rooms with people in them.”

Mara heard the edge in Noah's voice and remembered him at twenty-eight, refusing to call a room small if it contained a piano. She had loved that about him. Later, when her father called it a lack of ambition, she had failed to defend it.

“Noah is staying,” she said.

Stefan looked at her ring, then at Noah.

“Think carefully about what the audience will see.”

“For once, I'd rather think about what they'll hear.”

Her father left without taking off his coat. Ines followed to prevent the argument reaching the theatre staff.

Mara and Noah remained beside the piano.

“Why did you agree?” she asked.

“I wanted the work.”

“Only the work?”

He considered her. “I wanted to find out whether I could stand in a room with you and stay myself.”

She felt that more sharply than a declaration.

“And can you?”

“I don't know yet.”

He placed the draft agreement on the piano. Beside their names, someone had pencilled a promotional line: old friends reunited.

Noah crossed out friends.

“I won't do it like that,” he said. “If we're writing together again, you don't get to pretend I was never more than someone who played behind you.”