The Words He Chose

Create up to 20 seconds from 0:00. Available for free opening episodes. Preparing a clip downloads this episode on your device.

“You asked him to blame me?”

Owen nodded. He gripped the stair rail as if the floor might move beneath him.

“I was twenty-five and terrified.”

“I was twenty. I was terrified too.”

“I know.”

“Did you?”

He couldn't answer.

Isla turned away before she said something she could never take back. On the counter, Finn's forgotten screwdriver lay beside an empty champagne glass. An hour ago, she'd been kissing him. Now the room felt staged, as if everyone had known their lines except her.

Owen took one step closer.

“Don't,” she said.

He stopped.

“I want you to sleep upstairs tonight. I want you to speak to someone about what happened to you. And tomorrow, I want the whole truth. Those things can all be true at once.”

“I don't deserve—”

“Don't make me comfort you for hurting me.”

He lowered his head.

After he went upstairs, Isla sat until dawn. She didn't reread Finn's letter. She could not bear another piece of evidence that people had loved her badly and called it protection.

At seven, Bea arrived with coffee and found her still wearing the blue dress.

“That good a party?”

“That bad a family.”

Bea listened. She did not offer to murder anyone, which Isla appreciated more than she expected.

“What do you want?” Bea asked when she'd finished.

“To know whether any of it was real.”

“The kiss?”

“The years before it. The person I thought I was.”

Bea pushed the coffee toward her.

“You know who you are in the water. Start there.”

Isla looked at the morning light moving across the tables. In two hours, her first small group of beginners would arrive for a shore session. The updated forecast allowed it. She had checked twice.

For a moment, she considered canceling because her private life had become unbearable.

Then she stood.

Bea glanced at the dress.

“Want me to put that in the wash?”

“I'll do it.”

Upstairs, Isla pulled on her work clothes, then stopped with the blue fabric crushed between her hands. She had been happy in it before Finn came through the door. Mags had bought it for her, not for a man she might meet wearing it.

She spread it across the bed and smoothed the skirt.

Bea appeared with a folded towel.

“I liked myself last night,” Isla said.

“You're allowed to.”

“Even the part where I wanted him.”

Bea leaned against the doorway.

“You don't have to make every good minute evidence against yourself.”

Isla found a hanger. Her hands had finally stopped shaking.

“If he tells me something awful today, I don't want to look back and decide I deserved it because I kissed him.”

“Then don't give him that much power.”

There was no clever answer to that. Isla hung the dress where she could see it, rather than burying it beneath the clothes she needed for work.

Downstairs, a customer knocked on the glass. The day had begun without waiting for her to understand it.

“I'm going to change the sign,” she said. “Then we open.”

She tied back her hair and went downstairs. Whatever else she had lost, she still knew how to do her work.

The session was slow and ordinary. One woman admitted she hadn't put her face in the sea since childhood. A man who had boasted at the opening quietly asked to stay close to shore.

Isla gave each of them room. Nobody had to perform courage for her.

When the woman finally laughed at a small wave splashing her chin, Isla felt something inside herself settle. Confidence wasn't always a triumphant return. Sometimes it was one person trusting you enough to be frightened.

Finn waited above the beach when they finished.

He had brought neither flowers nor tools. She was grateful for that.

“After I get everyone back to the club,” she said.

“I'll wait.”

“You've said that before.”

He accepted the blow without looking away.

An hour later, they walked to the old lookout above the harbor. It was where they'd first kissed, and Isla regretted choosing it as soon as they arrived.

Finn seemed to recognize the place at the same moment.

“We can go somewhere else.”

“No. I'd like one memory back without a lie attached.”

He leaned against the stone wall, leaving her space.

“Owen told you,” he said.

“He told me he asked you to blame me.”

Finn closed his eyes briefly.

“Tell me from the beginning,” she said. “Not the version that makes you easiest to forgive.”

“The night of the accident, Owen and I argued outside the boat shed. He'd been drinking. He wanted to take the boat anyway. I told him he couldn't. He shoved past me.”

“And you let him?”

“I went to get help. By the time I came back, he'd launched.”

Isla stared down at the channel. In daylight it looked small, almost harmless. She knew better than to trust appearances now.

“I was already swimming,” she said. “Mags was watching from the beach.”

“Yes.”

“I heard the impact.”

“Yes.”

“I went toward him.”

Finn's face tightened.

“I saw you change direction. You weren't racing. You weren't showing off. You were trying to reach your brother.”

The words should have soothed her. Instead, they exposed how long she'd been denied them.

“Mags saw me from the beach. Did she know?”

“She challenged your father. More than once. She didn't hear my whole conversation with the reporter. When she found out about the letter, she kept it because she hoped one day you'd want it.”

“Why didn't she give it to me?”

“I don't know.”

For once, he did not invent an answer. Isla looked away. Her aunt had not been able to mend everything either. The thought hurt in a different way. She missed having someone alive to ask.

“The rescue crew got you both out,” Finn continued. “I helped when the boat came in. You were shaking so hard you couldn't speak. Owen kept asking what your father would say.”

“I remember Dad telling me I'd nearly killed him.”

Finn looked down.

“I heard.”

“And you said nothing.”

“No.”

Wind lifted a strand of hair across her face. Finn's hand moved, then stopped before touching her.

She was grateful. She hated needing to be grateful.

“In hospital, Owen asked me to keep quiet about the drinking. He said your father would never forgive him. He said everyone already thought you'd gone too far out.”

“And you believed that mattered more than what happened to me.”

“At first, I told myself I'd explain when you were better.”

“But you didn't.”

“No.”

“Why?”

Finn looked at her then, and there was no charm left in his face.

“Because each day I waited made telling the truth mean admitting what I'd already allowed.”

She folded her arms tightly across her chest.

“You wrote that letter.”

“Yes.”

“You wanted me back.”

“Yes.”

“But you wanted me back without knowing what you'd done.”

He swallowed.

“I thought loving you meant I couldn't be someone who hurt you. So I kept finding reasons not to look at what I'd done.”

Isla turned toward the water. For years she'd imagined a reunion in which one explanation would set everything right. It had never occurred to her that the explanation could make the wound larger.

Behind her, Finn's voice was rough.

“I'm not asking you to forgive me.”

“That's good.”

“I'll tell your father. I'll tell anyone who asks.”

“You don't get credit for returning something you took.”

“I know.”

She wiped at her cheek angrily. She had not wanted to cry in front of him again.

“Was last night guilt?”

“No.”

“Don't answer quickly because it sounds better.”

He waited until she faced him.

“I wanted to kiss you before the accident. I wanted to kiss you at the gate. I want to kiss you now, and I know I have no right to ask.”

Her body answered him with a rush of longing so fierce it felt like betrayal.

“That makes this worse,” she whispered.

“Yes.”

She remembered her father's final question. The newspaper. Finn had admitted making it sound as though she were to blame. But all he'd described was silence.

“There was an interview,” she said.

His face changed.

“What exactly did you tell the reporter?”

Finn's fingers tightened against the wall.

“Isla—”

“No. The exact words.”

He looked at her as if he knew this would be the thing she could not forgive.

“I said you dared Owen to follow you out.”

The wind dropped. She could hear the boats knocking softly against their moorings.

“But you saw what happened.”

“Yes.”

“You knew I didn't.”

Finn held her gaze.

“Yes,” he said. “I knew. And I told them you did.”